Well you just proved my point bro. You obviously haven't been in this situation. You compare playing 20*$10 online with playing live for 2 days and risking everything with one hand... Even though I agree it was a very very good hand. And I thought about it before folding it. But you implied it's a ridiculous decision when, regarding your comments, you obviously haven't been in this kind of situation. Obviously if I'm playing several mtt online I shove in this situation but it's way different here. Stick to what you know bro.
I did not write anywhere, that I think, it was "ridiculous". Of course there can be situations, where we deviate from the most long term optimal line for emotional or personal reasons. This is ok, and I do it sometimes as well. Maybe I failed to cash 20 times in a row, or I am playing a tournament slightly outside my
bankroll. So I REALLY want to get that min-cash, and I am willing to give up a bit of EV in the process.
But then no need to post the hand to a forum. After all only you can know, how important it was for you to cash in that tournament, and how much long term EV you were willing to give up to increase the chance of cashing.
As an outsider I can only look at this from a strict EV standpoint, and from such I certainly dont think, this was a good fold. And by even saying, you would have played it different, if it was an online MTT, you are also saying, that you know, it was not the right decision from an EV standpoint. Because otherwise why would it make a difference, what the stakes were, or how long the tournament had played?
Also I am somewhat surpriced, that you and many others seem to think, we can only fold or jam here. You did not mention his raise size, but most people today go for mini-raises or maybe up to 2,5BB, when stacks are this short. And that certainly leave enough room to call, see a flop, and only then decide, if we want to play for stacks.
If we was in fact making this very small open raise, I actually dont think, jamming is all that compelling with a 20+ BB stack. The risk/reward is not all that excellent, and he is probably playing rather close to perfect giving us action with KK+ and AK but possibly getting away from most of the
hands, that we crush.
Add to that the bubble factor, and I can certainly see just calling being the best play here. After all BTN is the seat on the table, where it makes most sense to have a calling range, other than BB, where we are getting a price and closing action.
There is probably an argument for playing our entire range as a call here, so that we are trapping him and the blinds with KK and AA. Stack to pot ratio is going to be around 3, which is nearly ideal for an overpair, and if someone think, they can squeeze light, then we have the hands to defend with.