Out of the two I'd pick cash cause I'm a cash player
. But I do play tourneys very occasionally and have some thoughts to expand towards them more in the future.
Cash games are tougher than tourneys but more technical & stable.
They are tougher because almost all the winning players put ton of work into their game. They've seen the same scenario multiple times & have a balance strategy to how to play in certain scenarios.
So out of the tourney & cash pools I'd say without a doubt that better poker players are cash players overall.
And the other thing is stability. Also you have the option to play whenever you want & leave whenever you want - So the freedom.
And tbh, cash players tend to do better at tourneys as well because they have the better understanding of the game at the beginning due to deep stack play.
I myself when I play tourneys do okay getting into the payouts by playing my normal game exploiting players, getting advantages over certain spots etc.
But when it comes to short stack play & people start shoving into each other, then things change a lot.
That bring to my next point. Which is tourneys involves a lot of variance & a lot of luck.
No matter how good you'll play in a tourney making all the right decisions, one flip that goes against you will determine everything. So the better player doesn't win always & perhaps will never get lucky in making some big amount.
It is so frustrating to know that if you could just hold on a bit longer you could've got paid 5 times more than you did. But you got in your aces as you should against K9off & the v caught trips.
So to counter this more volume is needed in tourneys as well as studying short stack play, push/fold charts & ICM considerations.
They big money in tourneys are at the final table & the
odds are very much against you making their but the reward is bigger.
And that's why I'm also looking forward to put some more time & volume into tourneys in the future.
But I'd say to all the up comers that say cash is hard or boring to ditch those thoughts & try them at least once in a while & to get better, because you'll become a better poker player overall by playing cash & you'll definitely have the edge in the tourneys in doing so.
P.S - I've noticed that in the CC article it says that you defend your blinds more in cash than you do in tourneys but in my experience this is not true. At least in the modern day tourneys we defend our Big blind a lot. Sometimes I even defend with 72s considering the price I'm getting. At cash this totally differs cause no antes plus the blinds doesn't increase so the ranges are tighter so stealing doesn't make much sense from certain spots.