Hand History Audit

[Bill_Hollorian]

I am looking for 1 persons hand history to audit. It must be poker tracker compliant. In exchange I will share critiques and compliments, with a few specific examples of places to improve.

Is anyone interested?

Bill

 

[Bill_Hollorian]

Oh also, you may have to answer a few questions if I dont understand why you made a particular play...

Bill

 

[Dennis C]

I'll get mine from Stars and e-mail it to you if you want. Let me know.

 

[F Paulsson]

Very generous of you, Bill, and people would be smart to take you up on it. Do you have any preferences on limit/no-limit?

 

[robwhufc]

This is a terrific idea, and I think one that could be offered on a site wide basis (with a panel of "experts" doing analysis, not just Bill of course). I don't think there is enough player development going on on the site.

 

[Dennis C]

Well Rob, Bill, FP, or whoever else wants it. I got my last 100 hands from stars last night. These are real money ring games for 7 card h/l, MTTs and freerolls for NLHE, and limit holdem and Omaha freerolls. So let me know if anyone wants to take a look or wants me to clean it up to just one game. Then let me know where you want it. Posted in a thread or mailed to you.

 

[tenbob]

I am looking for 1 persons hand history to audit. It must be poker tracker compliant. In exchange I will share critiques and compliments, with a few specific examples of places to improve.

Is anyone interested?

Bill

Sounds good Bill, i have a quick question, are you looking for a sample amount of hands (100 hands for example) or one or two of the more "interesting" ones ?

 

[Bill_Hollorian]

I am specifically interested in tournament results starting from the first hand going through the bubble, and a 4 hour session in a no limit ring game.
Limit does not lend itself to the agenda Im trying to resolve.

Thanks
Bill

Someone mention a panel, that would really be exciting. I would be interested to here a counter audit by Paulson, 4 dogs, twizzy, xd, the list goes on. If you are not mentioned in this list do not take offense Im just rattling a few off.

Bill

 

[Dorkus Malorkus]

You're welcome to my HH from the Stars $25 'Big One' if you're willing. As long as you're willing to accept "I have no idea why I did that - I am a donk" as reasoning behind silly hands.

Best part of 3 hours I think, 242 hands, placed 4/40.

 

[F Paulsson]

I like all ideas. I wish I had more time, but perhaps things will calm down in a few weeks.

 

[Four Dogs]

Bill, I am no where close to you or Fredricks league in hand analysis, but I can't think of a more valuable tool for anyone serious about improving their game than to have a meaningful body of work analysed by a panal of respected peers, (a council of elders?) not just selected bad beats or chest thumpers. I don't know of any other forum that has such a service. If there was, I'd be there. But for starters, just reviewing one members hand history is a great idea.

 

[Alon Ipser]

This is an excellent idea. It is similar to my idea about running a mock SNG and critiquing every hand as it was played but this sounds much more manageable. I will be looking forward to the critiques of whoever is decided.

 

[Jesus Lederer]

I very interested in sending my HH, but i have a few questions: Does the 4 hours session needs to be at a full table? What are the minimum limits and buy in for the ring games and MTT, respectively?
And finally the most important one: You said that the HH must be poker tracker compliant. I don´t know exactly what that means, but i don´t use PT. Is that a big problem?

 

[Dorkus Malorkus]

HHs from Stars, Party, UB, FT, Dise, Pacific, Cryptos and Absolute are all PT compliant in their raw format. Bill just wants to be able to import them into PT, I believe.

 

[Jesus Lederer]

Thanks Dorkus, that´s great because i have most of my money at FTP.
I would really like to send my HH, it would be very helpful to realize what are the big flaws in my game so i can improve my game, especially thinking that i´m in the beggining of my poker career.

 

[Dennis C]

I dug up a $1 Stars MTT history in which I finished 87 out of 2000. It was a 2+ hrs. and a Rocky road where I was leader and back of the pack. I'm going to post Hand audit 2 in a few mins. If anyone wants to play with it cool. If not oh well. I would like to know what I could've done to get farther. If someone wants me to send them this mail I will.

 

[Dennis C]

I dug up a $1 Stars MTT history in which I finished 87 out of 2000. It was a 2+ hrs. and a Rocky road where I was leader and back of the pack. I'm going to post Hand audit 2 in a few mins. If anyone wants to play with it cool. If not oh well. I would like to know what I could've done to get farther. If someone wants me to send them this mail I will.

Scrap that idea. My history had 300,000 leters in it and CC will only let you have 23,000 in any given thread. So if any one wants to get a hold of this HH let me know.

 

[tenbob]

Oh and Bill sorry my earlier post was rushed.

So do you want limit or N/L hands ? Tourney or cash games ? Any preferences to the $limits or does it matter at all.

Cheers.

 

[Dorkus Malorkus]

Oh and Bill sorry my earlier post was rushed.

So do you want limit or N/L hands ? Tourney or cash games ? Any preferences to the $limits or does it matter at all.

Cheers.

I am specifically interested in tournament results starting from the first hand going through the bubble, and a 4 hour session in a no limit ring game.
Limit does not lend itself to the agenda Im trying to resolve.

Thanks
Bill

Someone mention a panel, that would really be exciting. I would be interested to here a counter audit by Paulson, 4 dogs, twizzy, xd, the list goes on. If you are not mentioned in this list do not take offense Im just rattling a few off.

Bill

 

[Bill_Hollorian]

This is the thing I love about cardschat. I love how ideas expand, as everyone gets involved, just getting better and better.

Well, I suppose first we need to do 2 things.

Form this "panel"...
Let's start a list.

1.) Bill Hollorian
2.)
3.)

So as not to alleviate anyone of making an uncomfortable decision, can we run a poll or something to decide whos history we will audit?

Thanks Bill

 

[joosebuck]

ME since i got a royal yesterday! im snowed in from work today so ill get started playing some SNGs or limit ring games

 

[tenbob]

Form this "panel"...
Let's start a list.

1.) Bill Hollorian
2.)
3.)

I nominate F. Paulson.

 

[Tammy]

F.P. is a great nominee; I nominate Jesus Lederer, Dorkus, and tenbob. Just throwing some names out there. We have so many great players here, it's hard to just nominate a few.

 

[Greg]

F.P. is a great nominee; I nominate Jesus Lederer, Dorkus, and tenbob. Just throwing some names out there. We have so many great players here, it's hard to just nominate a few.

and if we can get him, Grum...........

 

[JAMILE1]

I nominate FP, Jesus Lederer, Dorkus, and tenbob

and if we can get him, Grum...........

Great choices and the X if he comes around