I'd like peoples opinions on this hand

T

Thereal

Guest
Joined
Nov 18, 2005
Total posts
2
This hand has caused some contention at a site I play at and I am posting it here to see what unbiased opinions would be on it....please note that the players 1 and 5 are husband and wife.....all opinions on how this hand was played are wanted.....

Hand Number: 244,852,015
Table Number: 3,210,208
Event Name: $250 GTD No Limit Holdem (#2211205)MNHB
Event Started: Wednesday November 16th 4:15:01 PM CST 2005
Event Type: XXXXXXXX Real Money Tournament
Event Buy-In: $15+$1.50 ($420 total prize pool)
Game: No Limit Hold 'em
Level XII: 200 Ante 500/1,000 Blinds (100 Minimum Chip)
Average Stack: 18,666.66 (10,000 starting chips)
Remaining Players: 15 (28 started)
Seat 1 : Player 1 starts with 9,300
Seat 2 : Player 2 starts with 20,000
Seat 3 : Player 3 starts with 14,100
Seat 4 : Player 4 starts with 8,700
Seat 5 : Player 5 starts with 36,300
Seat 6 : Player 6 starts with 16,800
Seat 7 : Player 7 starts with 9,900
Seat 8 : Player 8 starts with 18,700
Seat 8 : Player 8 has the dealer button
>>>DEALING HOLE CARDS<<<
Player 1 dealt down Kc 5c
Player 2 dealt down
Player 3 dealt down
Player 4 dealt down
Player 5 dealt down As 2s
Player 6 dealt down
Player 7 dealt down
Player 8 dealt down
Player 1 posts the ante 200
Player 2 posts the ante 200
Player 3 posts the ante 200
Player 4 posts the ante 200
Player 5 posts the ante 200
Player 6 posts the ante 200
Player 7 posts the ante 200
Player 8 posts the ante 200
Player 1 posts the small blind 500
Player 2 posts the big blind 1,000
Player 3 folds
Player 4 folds
Player 5 calls 1,000
Player 6 folds
Player 7 folds
Player 8 folds
Player 1 calls 500
Player 2 checks
>>>DEALING FLOP<<< [ Jd 3s 2d ]
Player 1 bets 1,000
Player 2 folds
Player 5 calls 1,000
>>>DEALING TURN<<< [ 8h ]
Player 1 bets 1,000
Player 5 calls 1,000
>>>DEALING RIVER<<< [ 2c ]
Player 1 bets 2,000
Player 5 calls 2,000
Player 1 cards were 5c Kc
Player 5 cards were 2s As
Player 5 wins 12,600 with three of a kind, deuces
>>>SUMMARY<<<
Hand Ended: Wednesday November 16th 5:56:01 PM CST 2005
Total Pot: 12,600
Board: [ Jd 3s 2d 8h 2c ]
Seat 1 : Player 1 (small blind) lost 5,200, showed hand [ 5c Kc ]
Seat 2 : Player 2 (big blind) lost 1,200, folded on the flop
Seat 3 : Player 3 lost 200, folded pre-flop
Seat 4 : Player 4 lost 200, folded pre-flop
Seat 5 : Player 5 bet 5,200, won 12,600, net +7,400, showed hand [ 2s As ]
Seat 6 : Player 6 lost 200, folded pre-flop
Seat 7 : Player 7 lost 200, folded pre-flop
Seat 8 : Player 8 (button) lost 200, folded pre-flop
 
H8POKER

H8POKER

Guest
Joined
Jun 4, 2005
Total posts
143
Well if 1 and 5 are husband and wife then it almost looks like there just moving some chips from 1 player to another, but if they were doing that why wouldnt they just go all in and move them all. On another note maybe #1 is just trying to hit the K which I think is just a bad play on there part. Atleast #5 hit the 2 on the flop.
 
T

Thereal

Guest
Joined
Nov 18, 2005
Total posts
2
Okay I should add these 2 people had been caught chip dumping a week or so previously....
 
Dorkus Malorkus

Dorkus Malorkus

HELLO INTERNET
Joined
Jul 12, 2005
Total posts
12,422
Player 1's turn and river bets are stupid. Either bet more or check/fold.

Player 5 not raising the river to put Player 1 all in is stupid.

They're either crap players or there's something suspicious going on, or most likely both. Would have looked much less suspicious if Player 5 had raised the river and Player 1 folded if they were trying to chip dump, but like I said they're probably both dishonest and terrible players.
 
Sammyv1

Sammyv1

Legend
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Total posts
1,618
Thereal said:
Okay I should add these 2 people had been caught chip dumping a week or so previously....

If they were acctually "CAUGHT" chip dumping for sure before, you should not be playing with them. This does look like a chip dumping case to me. The biggest problem is if they did do it before, everytime they play heads up it will always be on the other players minds (dumping). I say not to play witht these players again!
 
C

chicubs1616

Guest
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Total posts
570
Report this hand to the website it was played at...

If you saw them chip dumping earlier, do NOT play with them again...
 
ukpokerinfo

ukpokerinfo

Guest
Joined
Nov 19, 2005
Total posts
2
Here is that hand using my poker hand replayer tool :)
  • The blinds are 500 and 1000
  • Husband is in Small Blind position and Wife is in Middle position.
Husband
ck.gif
c5.gif
Wife
s1.gif
s2.gif
  • Wife calls
  • Husband calls
The Flop Comes
dj.gif
s3.gif
d2.gif
  • Husband bets 1000
  • Wife calls
The Turn card is
h8.gif
  • Husband bets 1000
  • Wife calls
The River card is
c2.gif
  • Husband bets 2000
  • Wife calls 2000
Created with the Poker Showdown tool from UK Poker Info.
 
gjshand

gjshand

Rock Star
Joined
Jun 22, 2005
Total posts
278
Sorry, I can't see what the fuss is about, Blinds are a decent size, the pair of twos isnt a raising hand and the K high is only betting the minimum, probably to find out where they are at. I understand the calls with the bottom pair, the only suspect move is the call on the river when they make their set, i would expect a re-raise. The call could be put down to not wanting to put the other one out but it doesnt look like chip passing to me.
 
Starting Hands - Poker Hand Nicknames Rankings - Poker Hands
Top