Doug Polk Critical of Poker Hall of Fame Selection Process

Doug Polk is highly critical of the Poker Hall of Fame, and he isn’t the only one after seeing the results of the recent nomination. Polk didn’t specifically criticize the voters for inducting Huck Seed, but he isn’t too thrilled with the final results of the voting.

Doug Polk poker

Doug Polk isn’t thrilled with the outcome of the recent Poker Hall of Fame votes. (Image: WSOP.com)

Seed was the top selection of the 30 living members of the Poker Hall of Fame, the only ones who were eligible to vote this year. The 1996 WSOP Main Event champ was a surprise selection. Many poker players predicted Isai Scheinberg, Patrik Antonius, or Antonio Esfandiari would win. Polk was quite surprised as well.

Polk didn’t specifically criticize the selection of Seed, but he called out the voters for many of their other selections, including Matt Savage finishing in second place. Savage is the WPT’s Executive Tour Director and is credited as an innovator responsible for the improvement of live tournament structures. The Upswing Poker founder, however, clearly doesn’t think he’s deserving of Poker Hall of Fame consideration.

He does consider Isai Scheinberg, the PokerStars founder, a worthy candidate. Scheinberg is considered largely responsible for the growth of online poker, and for ensuring Full Tilt Poker players finally got paid more than a year after Black Friday. He was also convicted of wire fraud for his connection to the Black Friday scandal at PokerStars. For that reason, Norman Chad, who was among the 2020 Poker HOF finalists, begged and pleaded that voters not induct Scheinberg.

Different Process this Year

The WSOP made some significant changes to the Poker Hall of Fame selection process. From 2005-2019, two nominees were inducted annually. Until this year, the media had a say in the voting process; instead, only living members of the HOF were allowed to vote on this year’s single inductee.

We’ll never know if the media would have chosen Seed this year. Perhaps, they would have voted in Scheinberg or Antonius, or maybe Esfandiari. But Seed, a four-time WSOP bracelet winner, and a past world champion, was the choice of the current HOF members. Few have been critical of that selection.

Jon Sofen
Written by
Jon Sofen
Semi-pro poker player with 17 years experience on the felt and more than five years working as professional poker media.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Did you know about our poker forum?

Discuss all the latest poker news in the CardsChat forum