What to do in this situation?

T

Tangerine 53

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 1, 2010
Total posts
367
Awards
1
Chips
4
NLHE SNG - $2+$0.25 on FT. Down to 3 players with Blinds - 80/160. Stack sizes:

BTN - 630
SB (Villain) - 9,850
BB (Hero) - 2,780

Button folds and Villain (LAG) shoves AI. He's shoved on me 3 times already since we got down to 4 handed and each time I've had nothing so have folded. I have KQs and I figure the villain's range to be quite wide. The factors I'm weighing up in determining whether to call here are:

1) Short stack is severely crippled and if I fold I have an excellent chance of at least coming 2nd and improving my cash.
2) If I call and win my chances of winning are improved dramatically as I'd be entering HU with at least 5.5k chips assuming SS doesn't hang around long.

Call or fold and why?
 
W

WiZZiM

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Oct 28, 2009
Total posts
5,008
Chips
0
Fold, your correct as you have an extreme shortstack present at your table, and secondly, were pretty deep here, we can definately find a better spot than this one..
 
damon789

damon789

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
May 9, 2009
Total posts
287
Chips
0
agreed

I will fall inline on this one this guy is playing bully and you are just about

guaranteed 2nd if you hang in there. if you only had equal chip stacks and

10bbs prob a difficult decision. here it's an easy fold the big stack might be

pushing with 52off if so you still only have 66% equity don't bump onions with

the bigstack be patient get HU and then take the big bully to task. :p PS ran a

similar situation on STNGOWIZ (ICM tool) and it said call with JJ+ so it suggests

only calling with the top 1.8% of hands KQs just falls into the top 4.8% of

hands
 
J

jpalumbos

Rising Star
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Total posts
23
Chips
0
I agree with Wizzim: Fold without hesitation.

Even if villain is pushing with a 10-7, you're still risking an easy 2nd place if he pairs up. If he's putting this kind of pressure on you, he'll put even more on Short-Stack. If you have JJ or better, go ahead and call, but otherwise, wait til you're heads up to start playing games with him.

-Joe P.
 
Shakes

Shakes

Visionary
Silver Level
Joined
Jun 10, 2008
Total posts
511
Awards
1
Chips
1
Agreed for what has been said above. IF the stack was higher and he had around the same amount of chps left Id be tempted to call but not with that low stack at the table
 
tomh7795

tomh7795

Visionary
Silver Level
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Total posts
545
Chips
0
Easy fold. Your risking more equity then your gaining in this spot. Let the short get knocked out then hope to gamble with hands like kq. Even if u were same stack as the short stack I might fold unless u have under10 bb because in a sng fold equity is worth a lot more then actual hand strength (unless u haven't got fold equity because of stacks of a very loose opponent or u pick up aces :D) if u didn't have fold equity then call (unless your deep stacked). I would rather push with 27 off with decent fold equity then call all in with kq. Of course depends on a lot of variables ( stacks, how your opponents are playing and if u still have fold equity). In this spot I would fold
 
Four Dogs

Four Dogs

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Total posts
4,298
Awards
1
Chips
17
I call without hesitation or remorse even if he shows AK or better. Play for the win. His range is huge and your not much of a dog to many of his legitimate holdings. If this were a satellite paying only the top 2 I might (probably would) fold, but in a normal structured tournament the difference in payouts between 1st and 2nd usually warrants the more aggressive play. The fact that he's seen you fold to his shove 3 times already makes a call with a hand as strong as KQ manditory and simple. Sorry, but only a nit folds here.
 
tomh7795

tomh7795

Visionary
Silver Level
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Total posts
545
Chips
0
I call without hesitation or remorse even if he shows AK or better. Play for the win. His range is huge and your not much of a dog to many of his legitimate holdings. If this were a satellite paying only the top 2 I might (probably would) fold, but in a normal structured tournament the difference in payouts between 1st and 2nd usually warrants the more aggressive play. The fact that he's seen you fold to his shove 3 times already makes a call with a hand as strong as KQ manditory and simple. Sorry, but only a nit folds here.

ur kiddin right? Calling there is awful. Lemme see sng wiz. Sng wiz that you should fold. Calling all in there is a -ev spot there.

Ur saying only a nit will fold there. I'm saying all decent sng players will fold there.
 
Four Dogs

Four Dogs

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Total posts
4,298
Awards
1
Chips
17
Fold, your correct as you have an extreme shortstack present at your table, and secondly, were pretty deep here, we can definately find a better spot than this one..
OK, then why raise at at all? Why not just sit out until the short stack busts or gets back into the hunt? Both situations are equally unappealing. If he doubles up a couple of times you may find yourself battling for 3rd rather than 2nd and wish you had taken your chances earlier with what was in all likelyhood the best hand. If he busts out then your heads up against a more aggressive opponent who has you massively outchipped.
 
Four Dogs

Four Dogs

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Total posts
4,298
Awards
1
Chips
17
ur kiddin right? Calling there is awful. Lemme see sng wiz. Sng wiz that you should fold. Calling all in there is a -ev spot there.

Ur saying only a nit will fold there. I'm saying all decent sng players will fold there.
No, I'm not kidding and Yes, only an EXTREME nit will fold in this situation. In fact, I'd probably call with any hand that I raise with.
 
NeverFold

NeverFold

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 12, 2010
Total posts
115
Chips
0
NLHE SNG - $2+$0.25 on FT. Down to 3 players with Blinds - 80/160. Stack sizes:

BTN - 630
SB (Villain) - 9,850
BB (Hero) - 2,780

Button folds and Villain (LAG) shoves AI. He's shoved on me 3 times already since we got down to 4 handed and each time I've had nothing so have folded. I have KQs and I figure the villain's range to be quite wide. The factors I'm weighing up in determining whether to call here are:

1) Short stack is severely crippled and if I fold I have an excellent chance of at least coming 2nd and improving my cash.
2) If I call and win my chances of winning are improved dramatically as I'd be entering HU with at least 5.5k chips assuming SS doesn't hang around long.

Call or fold and why?

I will fold. calling to All in is not really a good decision to do. You're right. Folding in order to maintain 2nd position in this tournament. But it will still depends on the cards (Flop, turn,river) if these favors your hand cards:)
 
tomh7795

tomh7795

Visionary
Silver Level
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Total posts
545
Chips
0
OK, then why raise at at all? Why not just sit out until the short stack busts or gets back into the hunt? Both situations are equally unappealing. If he doubles up a couple of times you may find yourself battling for 3rd rather than 2nd and wish you had taken your chances earlier with what was in all likelyhood the best hand. If he busts out then your heads up against a more aggressive opponent who has you massively outchipped.

We didn't raise at all. First of if we call and lose then we're out and the short stack gains 10% of the prize pool for folding. If we call and win then the short stack is still in the same position and your equity wouldn't have increased much while risking your entire equity. The short stack who will probably bust out soon if we fold. If he gets his stack up which is very unlikely then we still have a chance.
 
W

WiZZiM

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Oct 28, 2009
Total posts
5,008
Chips
0
ur kiddin right? Calling there is awful. Lemme see sng wiz. Sng wiz that you should fold. Calling all in there is a -ev spot there.

Ur saying only a nit will fold there. I'm saying all decent sng players will fold there.

firstly you should treat SNG wizard as a calculator, you shouldnt agree with it all the time, there are situations where you forget about it and go with a negative edge, usually either due to you being extremely shortstacked, or having a huge stack shoving into guys on the bubble. you shouldnt even say, that, oh i shove in these spots cos sng wiz told me too. sometimes you will have a tournament, and you look in wiz and see all ticks. well. fine. but if you really look through that tourney and review it properly, there are always leaks, and sometimes, since the moddelling is really bad, you may have made a few bad shoves here and there..

I call without hesitation or remorse even if he shows AK or better. Play for the win. His range is huge and your not much of a dog to many of his legitimate holdings. If this were a satellite paying only the top 2 I might (probably would) fold, but in a normal structured tournament the difference in payouts between 1st and 2nd usually warrants the more aggressive play. The fact that he's seen you fold to his shove 3 times already makes a call with a hand as strong as KQ manditory and simple. Sorry, but only a nit folds here.

i agree with the mindset that playing for the win is correct, here we only have one way to win the pot. but your correct in what your saying..

if you look through your finish distribution, you should have more 1st and 3rd places than seconds, and you should be bubbling a lot too.. if your playing correctly

so a really good long term distribution should look something like

13/11/12/12 something similar to that would be really good.

OK, then why raise at at all? Why not just sit out until the short stack busts or gets back into the hunt? Both situations are equally unappealing. If he doubles up a couple of times you may find yourself battling for 3rd rather than 2nd and wish you had taken your chances earlier with what was in all likelyhood the best hand. If he busts out then your heads up against a more aggressive opponent who has you massively outchipped.

ok, now if he makes a standard raise in this spot, im probably shoving. but here, he shoves. and whilst i agree with the ideal of going for first place, here is a spot where i really dont think were ahead enough to make a call..

ok so we have a read that he is loose. is he loose enough to shove in 8 2 off here? with the reads given, id say a range of 50/60% here would be toward the high end.

so against a range of 50%

equity win tie pots won pots tied
Hand 0: 55.767% 54.20% 01.56% 541104810 15606130.00 { KcQs }
Hand 1: 44.233% 42.67% 01.56% 425956162 15606130.00 { 33+, A2s+, K2s+, Q2s+, J4s+, T6s+, 96s+, 86s+, 76s, 65s, A2o+, K5o+, Q7o+, J7o+, T8o+, 98o }


so were basically flipping, now taking ICM considerations in, there is a shortstack present, and he will more than likely bust soon.. so money wise, its better to lay this down.

another thing we need to take into account is that were fairly deep still. there arnt any antes in FT games, so we have a lot more hands to see before the tourneys out, and im sure, we can find a better spot than flipping with KQ.

so again i agree with your idea of playing loose to try to get to first, you can take that too far sometimes, and i think, this is one of those spots.

now, if were like 10bb's here, i snap call. so you cant just assume that im a nit, because i feel its correct to fold in this specific situation.
im sure i cannot and willl not change your mind on this matter, but thats all i have to say really, gl at the tables.
 
dwolfg

dwolfg

Visionary
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Total posts
583
Chips
0
agree on the fold. Wait out the extreme short stack and try to outplay the big stack heads up.
 
Four Dogs

Four Dogs

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Total posts
4,298
Awards
1
Chips
17
We wan't to make the play that maximized our long term tournament equity. Sometimes that means we need to make tough calls and indeed it often means we even need to make some calls when we are likely behind. In this case based on the villains percieved aggressiveness we should assume we're ahead.

Let's look at this mathematically. Using the independent chip model (ICM), determining the current equity of each player at the table based on chip stack alone is relatively easy to do.

In this case, the villain, with t9850 has a 74% chance of taking 1st place for $9, a 24% chance of taking 2nd place for $5.40 and a 2% chance of taking 3rd place for $3.60 for a total equity of $8.03

The Hero with t2780 has a 21% chance of 1st, a 62% chance of 2nd and a 17% chance of 3rd for a total equity of $5.84

The Short Stack with only $630 is 1st 5% 2nd 15% 3rd 80% for a total equity of $4.13

Now we wnat to know which action, calling or folding offers the greatest increase or smallest decrease in total equity. Right away we know that folding is neg EV. The only question is if it's better or worse than calling. To do this we have to put the villain on a range of hands. In my opinion, given his profile as a LAG with a habit of attempting to steal Hero's blinds AND getting away with it I'm tempted to assign him any 2 cards but just to prove the point let's pretend he actually has some standards. Let's say he'll only shove all in with the top 25% of hands, Any Ace, Any Pair, and Any Broadway. Here's how that looks using Poker Stove.

equity win tie
Hand 0: 48.794% 47.05% 01.74% { KQs }
Hand 1: 51.206% 49.46% 01.74% { 22+, A2s+, KTs+, QTs+, JTs, A2o+, KTo+, QTo+, JTo }

This is so close to a push that when adding a few complete air hands to the equation I think it's safe to call it 50/50 for simplicity sake. What this means is that if we call, 50% of the time we lose and our equity instantly drops to $3.60, the cash out value for 3rd place.

The other 50% of the time we win our chip stack increases to t5560 and the villains stack decreases to t7070. lets run the numbers again.

Villain still has the edge based on stack size but his chance of scoring 1st has dropped to 53% 2nd place has increased to 41% and 3rd place to 6%. His total equity has dropped to $7.22

Hero has increased his chance of placing 1st to 42%, 2nd to 50% and 3rd has dropped to 8% for an increase in equity to $6.76

Let's not forget that standing still was not an option and your only choices were fold or call. Had Hero chickened out and folded his stack would have dropped to to t2620 giving him a remaining total equity of $5.78

Time to crunch the numbers.
Fold Equity - Call Equity = $5.78 -($6.76(when win) + $3.60(when lose))/2 = $5.18) = $.60
So, it looks as though folding to top 25% hands is slightly positive EV. I guess the question you have to ask is 1) Do you think villains range is greater or less than this? and 2) What do you do 3 hands from now when villain once again takes advantage of the FREE CHIPS sign on your forhead?
 
W

WiZZiM

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Oct 28, 2009
Total posts
5,008
Chips
0
now, forgive me, im really quite tired so i hope this post makes sense.. nice job on doing the icm calculations by hand, they seem to be correct, however.

what your saying here is that an error of $.60 is acceptable in a $2 game, when in reality its throwing away nearly 30% ROI, IF hes shvoing range is 25%

and to insinuate that if the shoving range is wider here this could slip into +EV simply isnt true. As you can see, its still a -0.97 mistake, which is 9%ROI give or take, that your throwing away.. there are times where we can take a negative edge, but here its not one of them.

unless you like to burn money. that is...
 

Attachments

  • inyourface.JPG
    inyourface.JPG
    108.2 KB · Views: 44
T

Tangerine 53

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 1, 2010
Total posts
367
Awards
1
Chips
4
As the OP I'd like to thank everyone for their contributions which I've read with great interest.

When I was in the situation this was a close one in my mind and that seems to be borne out by the consensus of responses here. For the record I actually did call swayed by the 'go for the win' mentality. Villain had TT (so I was a 46/54 dog) and busted me.

I posted this straight after as I wanted to see the responses but playing it back later felt I should have folded (looked at the ICM and it didn't quite justify the call) - as someone said on the thread there will be better spots. At the time I felt as though I should go for the win and also didn't want to keep getting pushed around so I made the stand.
 
S

suraj128

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 23, 2010
Total posts
80
Chips
0
I would say fold and let the bully take out the small stack giving you minimum 2nd place and a shot to win
 
Drunkard912

Drunkard912

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
Aug 11, 2009
Total posts
42
Chips
0
Take a shot i say. It sounds like he knows you are waiting on this other guy to bust. If he keeps running you over you wont have a prayer heads up anyway.
 
Top