With the stack $11458 and 4 < M < 5 (with the pot comprising with blinds and antes equal to $2610) your main options should be all-in or fold. But here you could call with very inexpensive investment of approx 1 BB being provided with huge pot
odds (6:1). While going all-in preflop mainly depends on the profile of UTG player calling is also very good option (again, in this particular case).
You hit the flop hard so i don't see how you could fold. So i'd say i did everything right but luck wasn't on your side.