Question for new online players please.

Status
Not open for further replies.
robwhufc

robwhufc

Cardschat Elite
Silver Level
Joined
May 25, 2005
Total posts
5,587
Chips
0
If you have recently started playing online poker, can I ask a few questions?

1) Are/were you aware that your opponents could be using computer programmes (such as pokertracker PAHUD and pokeroffice) that are artificially gaining information about your hand histories and your playing style, and are using that information in an attempt to get an advantage over you?

2) If yes, is that an issue or a concern? Have you purchased and used such a product yourself?

3) If no, is it a surprise? Is it a concern, and would you maybe not have started playing online if you had known about the poker assistance programmes before hand?

Thanks in advance for any responses.
 
Jack Daniels

Jack Daniels

Charcoal Mellowed
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Total posts
13,414
Chips
0
Note for new players: Just to be clear, Rob's questions are not about cheating or illegal software; he's referencing PokerTracker and PokerOffice as examples which are both allowed and legal for use at poker sites.

So the question really becomes, are you aware that there are programs out there, such as PokerTracker and PokerOffice, that allow you to gather hand histories at various sites so that you can both analyze your game as well as gain public information of your opponents' playing styles/habits that you can use towards future decisions once your sample size is minimally adequate?
 
c9h13no3

c9h13no3

Is drawing with AK
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 2, 2007
Total posts
8,819
Chips
0
Well, I got a bankroll together and started playing for real money about 8 months ago. When I started playing online in freerolls, I had no idea about poker tracker, ect. However, when I made the switch to playing for real money, I was aware of this fact.

I, personally, didn't mind. At the very low limits I play at, players rarely use this software. Additionally, players have very big leaks in thier game that are more important to notice than, say, their VPIP stats.

So maybe once I move up to say 25$ NL or more, I might consider buying pokertracker. But until then, its not a concern of mine.
 
P

pkrook

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Sep 15, 2007
Total posts
211
Chips
0
Well just to start...

...1) yes
2) no don't care
3) N/A
 
benevg

benevg

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Total posts
1,267
Chips
0
Well, I got a bankroll together and started playing for real money about 8 months ago. When I started playing online in freerolls, I had no idea about poker tracker, ect. However, when I made the switch to playing for real money, I was aware of this fact.

I, personally, didn't mind. At the very low limits I play at, players rarely use this software. Additionally, players have very big leaks in thier game that are more important to notice than, say, their VPIP stats.

So maybe once I move up to say 25$ NL or more, I might consider buying pokertracker. But until then, its not a concern of mine.

^^ that. except i started more like 5 months ago. and currently, i have enough leaks in my game to be visible without needing the help of a software. :-/
 
N

notevnifubeg

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
May 11, 2008
Total posts
48
Chips
0
Are there outside collections or libraries of player archives that provide aggregate histories from all available public poker sites (rooms as well as discussion forums) of players one has never encountered before?

I would imagine if available from a site publicly, someone is collecting and selling the data to those willing to pay for the convenience and completeness of information.

If these services do exist, for an experienced player, do you consider the data to be relevant and of value?

As a player who isn't very good, yet, I find my concentration is best utilized by focusing on my own data, and learning what it produces. Yes, I agree that some thought must be expended on the opposition, but as a neophyte, self examination is currently my greatest opportunity.
 
Jagsti

Jagsti

I'm sweet enough!
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Total posts
5,478
Chips
0
Buying datamined hands does occur, as does mutual swapping afaik.

And yes datamined hands are very useful to say the least. I haven't bought any, especially as my main site is pokerstars which doesn't allow datamining (so I see it as sort of unethical), but it's quite tempting.
 
robwhufc

robwhufc

Cardschat Elite
Silver Level
Joined
May 25, 2005
Total posts
5,587
Chips
0
I haven't bought any, especially as my main site is Pokerstars which doesn't allow datamining (so I see it as sort of unethical),

You think it's unethical because Pokerstars thinks it's unethical?

Not having a go, just seems a curious thing to say.
 
Pothole

Pothole

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 5, 2008
Total posts
2,507
Chips
0
Data mining of poker stars does take place, otherwise how does bluff Magazine know all the stats from everyone who plays there?
 
N

notevnifubeg

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
May 11, 2008
Total posts
48
Chips
0
Buying datamined hands does occur, as does mutual swapping afaik.

And yes datamined hands are very useful to say the least. I haven't bought any, especially as my main site is Pokerstars which doesn't allow datamining (so I see it as sort of unethical), but it's quite tempting.

How are they useful, what practical knowledge are you provided that improves your decisions in a meaningful way during a hand?

And please, I mean no offense, but if you have no experience from buying and using the player data real time, how do you know the information is useful during play and not a distraction from more relevant table clues or players yet to act?

Does too much information become a liability?
 
c9h13no3

c9h13no3

Is drawing with AK
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 2, 2007
Total posts
8,819
Chips
0
Does too much information become a liability?
In a game where we try to predict what an opponents cards are while they're face down, there's rarely such thing as too much information.
 
Jagsti

Jagsti

I'm sweet enough!
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Total posts
5,478
Chips
0
You think it's unethical because Pokerstars thinks it's unethical?

Not having a go, just seems a curious thing to say.

Well AFAIK pokerstars doesn't allow you to datamine. Yes people do it, but if they are caught then they are told to stop or are banned.

So if they say datamining is not allowed, then I'm not gonna do it. I think sharing of hands <ahem> is ok b/c at least the person you are interacting with has played in the hands, so thats ok in my book :D.

Don't get me wrong I have datamined on other sites that have allowed it. So Im not against it per se.

As to why stats are useful. Well, I'm a multi tabler, and keeping notes and observations on players is almost impossible unless you have a photgraphic memory or in my case PT and a HUD.

It can give you a host of stats on a villain, from there VPIP, pre flop betting range, to how often the steal blinds or folds their BB to a steal. It can give you stats on how often someone donk bets, how often they 3-bet or folds to a 3bet. Can you now see why this is a distinct advantage to have these stats on your HUD?
 
R

Raphael

Rising Star
Silver Level
Joined
May 23, 2008
Total posts
18
Chips
0
1) Yes, I am aware.
2) No, I think it's OK. I haven't gotten one myself, but am considering doing so.
 
M

moorjames

Rising Star
Bronze Level
Joined
May 23, 2008
Total posts
22
Chips
0
Hmm, I have been playing on only Pokerstars and didn't know that there was really such a program. But luckly, Pokerstars doesn't allow that, so I have no fear.

I think that such a program is kind of cheating, or unethical. Its really using technology to skew the results. At a table in person, you don't have all that information at hand, you have to use your own judgement and everything that you have from your previous experience to make a desicion. Oh well, thats my thoughts.
 
zachvac

zachvac

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Total posts
7,832
Chips
0
So if they say datamining is not allowed, then I'm not gonna do it. I think sharing of hands <ahem> is ok b/c at least the person you are interacting with has played in the hands, so thats ok in my book :D.


Well whether or not it is ok, it IS illegal on Stars. Of course it's next to impossible to enforce, but I believe on their site they state that sharing dbs is illegal, that all data you use must have been acquired yourself.
 
Jagsti

Jagsti

I'm sweet enough!
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Total posts
5,478
Chips
0
Well whether or not it is ok, it IS illegal on Stars. Of course it's next to impossible to enforce, but I believe on their site they state that sharing dbs is illegal, that all data you use must have been acquired yourself.

Didin't realize that Zach, but thx for pointing it out.
 
S

sboilyw

Rising Star
Bronze Level
Joined
May 24, 2008
Total posts
17
Chips
0
1. Am aware now, so thanks for heads up
2. But no, not worried - not consistent enough yet
- would love to see what it says about me, would be my only interest in acquiring the software

- Does anyone know if changing your id periodically would work to foil it?
- Seems like easy enough to have multiple users on most of these sites, might even want to play each with different personalities and see what works best
?
 
F Paulsson

F Paulsson

euro love
Silver Level
Joined
Aug 24, 2005
Total posts
5,799
Awards
1
Chips
1
You think it's unethical because Pokerstars thinks it's unethical?

Not having a go, just seems a curious thing to say.
Actually, I think it's okay to think it unethical to datamine on Stars, but not on FullTilt (or whatever site that allows it) for no other reason than the specific rules on the site. It's just a matter of playing by the same rules as everybody else. I don't datamine (honestly, it's more because I'm lazy than for some spectacular reason involving integrity) but I don't consider people who datamine on FullTilt unethical. I would, however, object to the same people doing it on Stars. I can choose not to play at sites that allow datamining, so by playing at Stars, I'm essentially trusting my opponents not to know stuff about me that happened in hands I didn't play against them. If they violate that trust by doing something they've agreed not to when signing up at the site, I consider that unethical.
 
S

sboilyw

Rising Star
Bronze Level
Joined
May 24, 2008
Total posts
17
Chips
0
Notes on Poker Stars

Speaking of hands they didn't play with you, for hands they did play with me I thought the notes feature would be great to keep track of players I had played, but either I've never come up against someone again, or notes are only good for the event you're in. Can anyone confirm that pokerstars software doesn't keep the notes you make? I'vemade enough that I think I would have seen one again.:confused:
 
K

KacieNicole

Rising Star
Silver Level
Joined
May 25, 2008
Total posts
17
Chips
0
I am new to playing poker and made my first deposit just recently. Yes I knew there were programs out there being used when I used to just play for real money. However I don't really know how they work or what they actually accomplish AND i for sure didnt know that it was LEGAL AND I CAN USE ONE TOO lol ;)
 
dmorris68

dmorris68

Legend
Loyaler
Joined
May 27, 2008
Total posts
6,788
Awards
2
Chips
0
The software issue is well known among people that have played online for any length of time, I would think. Just look at the PokerStars lists to see just an example of the number of programs out there.

I personally don't have an issue with keeping stats on players that you have played before because it's the online equivalent of "making book" on live players that you've played. You loose so much in the way of physical tells, emotion, etc. in playing online vs live that, IMO, compiling numbers on your opponents is a reasonable alternative, and not at all unethical -- especially when the site specifically allows it. Remember also that these tools are extremely useful not only for analyzing others' play, but your own as well. It's a lot easier to look at past performance and spot leaks, trends, how you play certain hands, etc. Even without considering other players' stats, these tools can make you a better player.

Now datamining is another thing altogether. I don't believe it's fair to have extensive knowledge of how somebody plays that you've never played before. So I appreciate the fact that PokerStars disallows this, and while I know it happens anyway, I feel a little more comfortable playing there than somewhere else where mining is allowed or even encouraged.

This has been posted many times I know, but for the benefit of the folks posting here who are new and unaware of these programs, here is the current PokerStars lists of allowed and disallowed software.

Prohibited Online Poker Software Programs

ALLOWED:
  • Can you give me some examples of acceptable programs?
  • The following are examples of programs which are permitted:
    1. Calculatem Pro
    2. Coach Rounder
    3. Draw Poker Source
    4. GameTime+
    5. Holdem Genius
    6. Holdem Indicator
    7. Holdem Manager
    8. Holdem Partner
    9. Holdem Ranger
    10. Omaha Poker Coach
    11. Paragon Poker Pal
    12. Poker Academy Prospector
    13. PokerAce HUD
    14. Pokerbility
    15. Poker Buddy
    16. Poker Butler
    17. PokerEval (Registered Version Only)
    18. Poker EV
    19. Poker Evolver
    20. Poker Indicator
    21. Poker Juggernaut
    22. Poker Office
    23. Poker Potjie
    24. Poker Pro 2007
    25. Poker Sharpener
    26. Poker Sidekick
    27. Poker Sniffer
    28. Poker-Spy
    29. PokerStat
    30. Poker Stove
    31. Poker Tracker
    32. Poker Vitals
    33. Poker Weapon
    34. Poker Wingman
    35. PPA Poker Calculator
    36. SmartBuddy
    37. Star Tracker
    38. Stud Inspector v1
    39. Table Shark
    40. Telescope by SpadeIt
    41. Texas Calculatem
    42. ThePokerDB
    43. Tournament Indicator
    44. Tournament Shark
This list was last updated May 21st, 2008.
NOT ALLOWED:
  • In general, what kinds of programs are prohibited?
  • The following types of programs are prohibited:
    1. Any program that shares hole card data with other players or programs is colluding, and is prohibited.
    2. Any program that works off of a central database of player profiles or hands played is prohibited.
    3. Any program that plays without human intervention (a "bot") or reduces the requirement of a human playing. For instance, an "auto-folder" is prohibited.
    4. The practice of datamining (observing games as a non-player for extended periods in order to build up a large database of hand histories for future reference) is prohibited.
    5. Any software that offers direct game play advice on the appropriate action to take, and which is also programmable or configurable beyond a very basic level.
  • Can you give some examples of programs which are prohibited?
  • The following are examples of programs which are prohibited at all times:
    1. Advanced Poker Calculator
    2. Gambot
    3. hhSmithey
    4. Holdem Hawk
    5. Holdem Pirate
    6. Holdem Inspector a.k.a. Online Holdem Inspector
    7. iHH Harvester
    8. Magic Holdem
    9. Mandraker
    10. Open Holdem Bot
    11. OPI Wizard
    12. PokerAnalytics
    13. Poker Android
    14. Poker Bot+
    15. Poker Bloodhound
    16. Poker Crusher
    17. Poker Edge
    18. Poker Inspector a.k.a. Online Poker Inspector
    19. Poker Mate
    20. Poker Prophecy
    21. Poker Sherlock
    22. Poker Table Manager
    23. Real Poker Rankings
    24. SharkScope [Pending]
    25. Sit n' Go Brain
    26. Sixth Sense
    27. SmartCollector a.k.a. Mixed Harvesters
    28. SpadeEye
    29. Stars Hand History (SHH)
    30. StarSpy
    31. Texas Auto Fold
    32. TheCashDB
    33. WinHoldem
    This list was last updated May 21st, 2008.

    There are some programs which have legitimate uses for analysing your game, but which are not appropriate for use during play. For example, ICM (Independent Chip Model) and Nash Equilibrium tools may be used for post-game analysis and for studying hands which you have previously played. However, you may not use such a tool while the PokerStars software is open.

    Some examples of programs which are prohibited only while PokerStars is running are:
    1. Insight Poker Hound
    2. Sit n’ Go End Game Tools
    3. SitnGo Wizard
    4. SNG Power Tools
    5. Spade ICM
    6. STT Analyzer by PokerSoftwareTools
    This list was last updated May 21st 2008.
 
T

Tugboat Complex

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
Nov 21, 2007
Total posts
34
Chips
0
1. No
2. No
3. No
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top