$50 PL O 6-max: Thoughts on river fold. Yes, it was the second nuts.

Villain is unknown, only 1 orbit at the table and this is the first time he has shown aggression post flop. The other villain over values a lot of hands. I call the turn with the intention of calling a small bet on the river/ folding if the board pairs etc. My reasoning for folding is that most villains (competent) will not be betting J high flushes or worse on this river or they would bet a lot smaller. Granted, my hand is underrepped a ton but I just do not see someone betting pot here with a lot of weak flushes.

Am I stupid? BTW, before someone says something about preflop, the UTG raiser was raising close to every hand and the table is fairly loose.

Full Tilt Pot-Limit Omaha, $0.50 BB (6 handed) - Full-Tilt Converter Tool from FlopTurnRiver.com

saw flop

UTG ($50)
CrackerAssFantastic (MP) ($88.10)
CO ($77.80)
Button ($141.15)
SB ($10.50)
BB ($50)

Preflop: CrackerAssFantastic is MP with 10 , Q , 5 , J
UTG bets $1.75, CrackerAssFantastic calls $1.75, 1 fold, Button calls $1.75, SB calls $1.50, BB calls $1.25

Flop: ($8.75) 4 , 2 , 3 (5 players)
SB checks, BB checks, UTG checks, CrackerAssFantastic checks, Button checks

Turn: ($8.75) A (5 players)
SB checks, BB bets $8.75, 1 fold, CrackerAssFantastic calls $8.75, Button calls $8.75, 1 fold

River: ($35) 6 (3 players)
BB bets $35, CrackerAssFantastic folds, 1 fold

Total pot: $35 | Rake: $1.75

good fold imo, as you say it's hard to imagine pot turn/pot river being anything other than the nut flush without a read on Villain being pretty gutsy or fishy.

You have a straight flush IMO.

Doesn't it become more difficult for him to have a flush the more flush cards that come out? There's only 6 clubs left in the deck...

However, in the brief period I played PLO8, villains always had the nuts when they were hitting the bet pot button, so folding can't be far bad.

Fold preflop. Yea you're double suited but neither is nut and you have a hanger (the 5) which totally kills your hand for big straight draws

As far as river goes, when BB pots into 2 opponents he has the K high flush or a naked Kc. Calling down 2 pot bets with non nut flushes is generally a recipe for disaster in PLO. Fold. If he bluffed you fine -- that's the strength of the naked nut bluff and why it's so effective

Edit: I'm assuming villains at this level to be competent. I don't play this low though, so if typically people will bet non nut flushes in this fashion at these stakes then we can profitably call