Not to sound like a broken record but you are playing AJo from MP1. This hand is exactly why you shouldn't do that. There are just too many hands that beat you here. If you bet he could re-raise you and if you check he could bet and you won't know where you stand without committing a lot of chips to a marginal hand like AJo.
True with a range of 45/12 he is playing such a wide range but what hands that called your preflop raise and then re-raise you have you beat? The problem with playing back at super loose players is if you re-raise them all-in you need to be ahead of the middle of his raising & betting range not his limping/ calling range. With a PFR of 12 he could be raising with any Ace (this is actually pretty common at 2nl/ 5nl) so you could be against AA AK AQ A9 A5. These players will limp/ call with virtually ATC but when they raise they at least have an A, K or pair.
Do yourself a favor, save AJo for LP1, not MP1.
Disagree completely. Not saying this isn't a fold but against the right villain it's certainly not.
Villain in this hand is 46/0/3 over about 35 hands:
Full Tilt - $1 NL - Holdem - 9 players
Hand converted by PokerTracker 3
UTG+1: $119.20
Hero (MP): $102.90
MP+1: $82.75
LP: $100.00
CO: $93.95
BTN: $57.75
SB: $144.40
BB: $100.00
UTG: $94.35
SB posts SB $0.50, BB posts BB $1.00
Pre Flop: ($1.50) Hero has T:spade: A:spade:
fold,
fold,
Hero raises to $3.50,
fold,
fold,
fold,
BTN calls $3.50,
fold,
fold
Flop: ($8.50, 2 players) 4:club: K:spade: A:diamond:
Hero checks,
BTN bets $4.00,
Hero calls $4.00
Turn: ($16.50, 2 players) 3:diamond:
Hero bets $9.00,
BTN calls $9.00
River: ($34.50, 2 players) 7:diamond:
Hero bets $13.00,
BTN raises to $41.25 and is all-in,
Hero calls $28.25
BTN shows 5:spade: A:club: (One Pair, Aces)
Hero shows T:spade: A:spade: (One Pair, Aces)
Hero wins $114.00
Villain here is 40/18/2
Full Tilt - $1 NL - Holdem - 9 players
Hand converted by PokerTracker 3
BB: $210.40
UTG: $183.15
UTG+1: $66.50
MP: $86.70
MP+1: $102.25
LP: $100.60
CO: $64.50
Hero (BTN): $111.45
SB: $100.00
SB posts SB $0.50, BB posts BB $1.00
Pre Flop: ($1.50) Hero has J:heart: A:spade:
fold,
fold,
fold,
MP+1 raises to $2.00, LP calls $2.00,
fold,
Hero raises to $11.00,
fold,
fold,
MP+1 calls $9.00,
fold
Flop: ($25.50, 2 players) J:club: 9:diamond: A:diamond:
MP+1 checks,
Hero bets $18.00,
MP+1 calls $18.00
Turn: ($61.50, 2 players) 9:heart:
MP+1 checks,
Hero bets $35.00,
MP+1 calls $35.00
River: ($131.50, 2 players) 6:heart:
MP+1 bets $38.25 and is all-in,
Hero calls $38.25
MP+1 shows A:heart: 4:heart: (Two Pair, Aces and Nines)
Hero shows J:heart: A:spade: (Two Pair, Aces and Jacks)
Hero wins $205.00