I would definetly call here, don't forget it's 2nl.
I think you'd often be up against AJ or something like that in these spots.
J's therefore could be his hand, but AKd and AJ are also.
There are 4 hands that beat you here, AA,JJ,22,55 , (AA is really unlikely) so it's a call 100% of the time,
His stats tell us he's a bad player, and these players tend to push any TP, even tho they are nitty pre-flop.
plus it's only 1.18 into a 3$ pot, so you are definetly getting the right odds
to call here.
So yea, never fold it Imo