When The Dealer Screws Up

X

Xavier

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Total posts
437
Chips
0
I was playing in a tournament one day and just 2 players were involved in a pot, and a short stack was all in against another guy.
The dealer did not burn a card between the turn and river and the short stack won the pot and the dealer gave him the chips.
Neither player noticed that he had not burnt a card but one of the other players pointed it out. The dealer confirmed it and changed the river card, which changed who had the best hand, and the dealer took the chips back off the short stack and gave them to the bigger stack.
The short stack guy was really pissed.
Should the pot not have stayed as it was as the dealer had begun shuffling his cards for the next hand and he had already given the chips back to the short stack guy. There must be a limit to when you can go back and change a hand if a mistake is made.
 
lennytoon

lennytoon

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
May 26, 2009
Total posts
47
Chips
0
lennytoon

all hands should be burned,
dealer sacked and a black eye if i was the small blind lol
 
tenbob

tenbob

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
May 16, 2005
Total posts
11,221
Awards
1
Chips
20
If I was the shortstack in this hand I would certainly have called the TD for a ruling on this. My understanding is that once the pot is awarded and the cards gathered for the next deal (obv as he was shuffling for the next deal) then there can no longer be a dispute.

We had this situation on the final table of a tourney a few weeks back, the dealer mis-called a hand and awarded the pot to the wrong person. Once the next hand started the players started to question it, the TD was called and said that the pot was awarded, too late.
 
dd_decker

dd_decker

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 24, 2009
Total posts
454
Chips
0
If any of the two players cards touched the muck, I think the hand should have been valid even theough there was no burn. If no cards touched the muck, I still think the hand should have stood, as it was too late, chips were already awarded, but I don't know, it just seems fair.
 
Stu_Ungar

Stu_Ungar

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
May 14, 2008
Total posts
6,236
Chips
0
When in doubt, call the floor manager / tournament director for a ruling. Obviously if you aren't in the hand, just keep quiet.
 
tgarner

tgarner

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 17, 2009
Total posts
163
Chips
0
That's the one thing I hate about our local home games. People that are not involved in the hand calling out the possabilities on the board. And sometimes the people involved havn't noticed that possability. Really torks me off, especially when I am in the hand.
 
ythelongface

ythelongface

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Total posts
2,647
Awards
1
Chips
2
If I was the shortstack in this hand I would certainly have called the TD for a ruling on this. My understanding is that once the pot is awarded and the cards gathered for the next deal (obv as he was shuffling for the next deal) then there can no longer be a dispute.

We had this situation on the final table of a tourney a few weeks back, the dealer mis-called a hand and awarded the pot to the wrong person. Once the next hand started the players started to question it, the TD was called and said that the pot was awarded, too late.
i concur. thats been my experience in tourneys as well
 
OzExorcist

OzExorcist

Broomcorn's uncle
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Total posts
8,586
Awards
1
Chips
1
If I was the shortstack in this hand I would certainly have called the TD for a ruling on this. My understanding is that once the pot is awarded and the cards gathered for the next deal (obv as he was shuffling for the next deal) then there can no longer be a dispute

^ this. Once the pot's been awarded and the shuffle for the next hand has begun there's really not a lot you can do, but by all means pause and call the TD over.

I'm not sure I understand how this hand wound up though - someone pointed out that card didn't get burned so the dealer went back and fixed it, which resulted in the pot being awarded to the other player... but he'd already started shuffling for the next hand?!? That is definitely not right and the TD ought to be called.

Stu_Ungar said:
Obviously if you aren't in the hand, just keep quiet.
^ definitely not this. Dealers are human, they make mistakes from time to time. I'm one, and I know I do. Not very often, because I'm awesome, but it happens.

If you notice a mistake happening, say something - even if you're not in the hand.

dd_decker said:
If any of the two players cards touched the muck, I think the hand should have been valid even theough there was no burn. If no cards touched the muck, I still think the hand should have stood, as it was too late, chips were already awarded, but I don't know, it just seems fair.

^ also not this, I think.

TDA Rule 29 says:

29. Killing Winning Hand
Dealers cannot kill a winning hand that was tabled and was obviously the
winning hand. Players are encouraged to assist in reading tabled hands
if it appears that an error is about to be made.


This means that even if the winning hand touches the muck, it's not dead as long as it was tabled and if it's possible to correct the error the dealer can do so. Note also that the rule encourages players to point out dealer errors in this regard.

I don't know if we've got enough information on this hand to categorically say who was right or what should have happened, but the basic principles don't change: if something wierd happens, call the tournament director over before the next hand commences.
 
Stu_Ungar

Stu_Ungar

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
May 14, 2008
Total posts
6,236
Chips
0
^ definitely not this. Dealers are human, they make mistakes from time to time. I'm one, and I know I do. Not very often, because I'm awesome, but it happens.

If you notice a mistake happening, say something - even if you're not in the hand.

Its not your place to police the table. By pointing out this mistake, one of the two players is going to be upset. If they haven't noticed then they wont think twice about it.
 
LeanAndMean

LeanAndMean

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
Sep 2, 2007
Total posts
1,560
Awards
4
Chips
0
Wow, If I had been that short stack I would have made loud angry noises all the way to the top of the chain of command. should not have been redone.
 
OzExorcist

OzExorcist

Broomcorn's uncle
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Total posts
8,586
Awards
1
Chips
1
Its not your place to police the table. By pointing out this mistake, one of the two players is going to be upset. If they haven't noticed then they wont think twice about it.

That's true, it's not your place to police the table. For the most part that's the dealer's job and they're plenty capable of doing it themselves.

But I'm a dealer, and I'm telling you now: absolutely say something if you see a major error (like a pot being awarded to the wrong person, or the wrong number of cards being dealt or something) being made or about to be made. You can see above, the TDA rules encourage you to do the so if there's a ****-up of this magnitude about to be made.

If you're right, none of the players in the hand have any grounds to be upset.
 
Stu_Ungar

Stu_Ungar

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
May 14, 2008
Total posts
6,236
Chips
0
That's true, it's not your place to police the table. For the most part that's the dealer's job and they're plenty capable of doing it themselves.

But I'm a dealer, and I'm telling you now: absolutely say something if you see a major error (like a pot being awarded to the wrong person, or the wrong number of cards being dealt or something) being made or about to be made. You can see above, the TDA rules encourage you to do the so if there's a ****-up of this magnitude about to be made.

If you're right, none of the players in the hand have any grounds to be upset.

In my experience, involving yourself in an argument, in which you have no formal role, is the quickest way to get your car scratched!!

Hence, if it dosen't effect me, and no one's life is at stake, I will stay will stay out of it.
 
nevadanick

nevadanick

Back to work ... zzzzz
Silver Level
Joined
Oct 3, 2007
Total posts
8,477
Chips
0
Its not your place to police the table. By pointing out this mistake, one of the two players is going to be upset. If they haven't noticed then they wont think twice about it.

It IS my place to be involved in anything that happens on a live table that I have MY money on - ring or tourney.

I've played live since '69 and have never seen anyone (iirc) faulted for commenting on a hand outcome or a table action error. OTOH, I have seen people faulted for noticing an error and NOT saying something in a timely manner.

In this case as just one example, I could have been the next short-stack and NOT saying anything about the missing burn card could have meant the difference between shorty being eliminated or stacked, making me the shorty due to an error. I have EVERY right to say or make comments about any of the table action whether I'm in the hand or not.

In my experience, involving yourself in an argument, in which you have no formal role, is the quickest way to get your car scratched!!

Hence, if it dosen't effect me, and no one's life is at stake, I will stay will stay out of it.

I don't think this post was about continuing an argument 'after' the fact, it was about what and who has a say in hand and dealing/card progression. If 'anyone' at the table had called out the missing burn card, the error would never have happened and shorty would have been out, providing of course that the burn card correction would have given him a losing hand.
 
OzExorcist

OzExorcist

Broomcorn's uncle
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Total posts
8,586
Awards
1
Chips
1
In my experience, involving yourself in an argument, in which you have no formal role, is the quickest way to get your car scratched!!

Hence, if it dosen't effect me, and no one's life is at stake, I will stay will stay out of it.

*shrugs*

Your call, I guess you're not obliged to point it out.

Put yourself in the other player's shoes though - the dealer makes a mistake and awards a pot that should've been yours to another player. You don't notice but someone else that folded preflop does. Are you really gonna bite their head off if they point out the mistake?
 
Stu_Ungar

Stu_Ungar

Legend
Silver Level
Joined
May 14, 2008
Total posts
6,236
Chips
0
Well I'm not obviously.. I going to be over the moon... but the guy who thought he had won the pot (especially if its a large one) may be very upset. When emotions run high, some people do some very odd things.
 
Suited Frenzy

Suited Frenzy

CardsChat Elite
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 13, 2007
Total posts
3,590
Chips
0
I'm not quite sure if there's a 'limit' to when the dealer can go back & deal the cards correctly but I do know that if this was you in the hand, then you should ALWAYS get the floor manager &/or tournament director there asap.

Being you were playin' tournament style & weren't in the hand & every person that goes out is a benefit to you, I wouldn't say anything about it. Let them figure it out, if the ss goes out good, if he stays, he's still a ss & you have a chance to take his chips in future hands.
 
OzExorcist

OzExorcist

Broomcorn's uncle
Bronze Level
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Total posts
8,586
Awards
1
Chips
1
Well I'm not obviously.. I going to be over the moon... but the guy who thought he had won the pot (especially if its a large one) may be very upset. When emotions run high, some people do some very odd things.

Meh, that's what casino security's for - if he is indeed that big a douchebag. The pot was never his to begin with, so he's really got no reason to get upset.
 
M

mig2169

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 22, 2008
Total posts
423
Chips
0
I play regular at commerce casino in LA, and there is allways everytime i go there some sort of crap with a dealer, it is not there fault but most of the time a floor man is called over and what ever happened is talked through usually to the satisfication to both parties, i have never came across something like that but most of the time when both hands hit the muck the hand is over no matter what happens. When playing live allways hold on to your cards until the very last second when the dealer asks for them don't through them in the middle, just turn them over and hold on to them until you are satisfied you have won or lost.
 
jordanbillie

jordanbillie

Legend
Bronze Level
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Total posts
3,742
Awards
3
Chips
161
I would point out a dealer mistake in a heartbeat! The dealers job is to protect the integrity of the game and deal fair, if he does something wrong, or a pot is going towards someone who is not the rightful owner of it, well that is not a fair game.
 
E

Ecomdan

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Apr 25, 2009
Total posts
241
Chips
0
You think thats bad? I was at a cash table where the dealer made a mess of a pot, there was a 4 way all in all of different amounts and the dealer totally messed up the side pots. Play was stopped for about 30 min I just got up and found another table cuz tempers were running really high, poor dealer looked like she was about to cry.
 
Jack Daniels

Jack Daniels

Charcoal Mellowed
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Total posts
13,414
Chips
0
Its not your place to police the table.
Well, I have to side with Oz on this one based on our old commonly accepted friend, Robert's Rules of Poker v10: 3. Any player, dealer, or floorperson who sees an incorrect amount of chips put into the pot, or an error about to be made in awarding a pot, has an ethical obligation to point out the error. Please help keep mistakes of this nature to a minimum.

As far as I'm concerned, everyone at the table (assuming they aren't intentionally trying to cheat) should be looking to keep the game honest and fair. Any person that sees an error and intentionally fails to bring it to the tables' attention is no better than someone actually sitting at the table purposely cheating.


In regards to the OP, Robert's Rules lists a rule directly on point:

6. If the dealer fails to burn a card or burns more than one card, the error should be corrected if discovered before betting action has started for that round. Once action has been taken on a boardcard by any player, the card must stand. Whether the error is able to be corrected or not, subsequent cards dealt should be those that would have come if no error had occurred. For example, if two cards were burned, one of the cards should be put back on the deck and used for the burncard on the next round. If there was no betting on a round because a player was all-in, the error should be corrected if discovered before the pot has been awarded.

As such, the fact he didn't burn a card between the turn and river became irrelevant the moment once action proceeded.
 
Last edited:
jordanbillie

jordanbillie

Legend
Bronze Level
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Total posts
3,742
Awards
3
Chips
161
You think thats bad? I was at a cash table where the dealer made a mess of a pot, there was a 4 way all in all of different amounts and the dealer totally messed up the side pots. Play was stopped for about 30 min I just got up and found another table cuz tempers were running really high, poor dealer looked like she was about to cry.

Lol I have seen this before when a dealer completely messes up the side pots. Once when I was behind another dealer waiting to come in, there was a multiway allin and when the hand was over a player only eligible for the main pot had the best hand and the dealer took the side pot, massed it into the main pot and started to push it to that player. The player that was supposed to win the side pot was like, "WTF!". The dealer just took some of the now one big pot and split it to the side and gave it to that player. I was behind and I can't say a word, I couldn't believe that mess!
 
S

Syfted

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Jun 24, 2008
Total posts
205
Chips
0
If the error is correctable, I think it is reasonable here to try and correct it. That is, if the player who won the pot without the burns hasn't started stacking the chips from the pot yet, I think the error should be repaired. If he has started stacking those chips, the hand is over, because the error would become impossible to correct.

This is a terribly embarrassing situation (or should be) for the poor dealer as well.

And players have an obligation to protect the game from human error.
 
S

sharpone

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 24, 2009
Total posts
132
Chips
0
Ha ha haa what do you do

Honestly i think the dealer makes a mistake every time i lose a hand lol. But honestly i think this is a ggod question, there should be some reparations when the game is altered especially due to human error. The game has enough luck factor as it is, dont need extra second chances. :eek:
 
Tygran

Tygran

Cardschat Elite
Silver Level
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Total posts
1,757
Chips
0
In my experience, involving yourself in an argument, in which you have no formal role, is the quickest way to get your car scratched!!

Hence, if it dosen't effect me, and no one's life is at stake, I will stay will stay out of it.


I understand the sentiment but two comments.

First of all..I agree with OZ (I am a dealer as well), you should point out a major error if you see one.

Secondly...especially if this is late in the tourny... the elimination of a player vs a shorter player doubling up most definitely affects you.
 
Top