I vote PAD for a couple of reason:
1. Less editing-- they show almost every hand, not just the ones with lots of action. Maybe you could argue that this makes it less exciting, but it is certainly closer to reality.
2. You can hear the table talk better-- less commentary covering the table chat. Again, you might argue that the table chat is boring (or non existent), but I guess verisimilitude wins out again in my opinion.
3. Shana, mmmmmmmm, Shana.