Originally Posted by OzExorcist
Note that it shouldn't have anything to do with whether you've got automuck turned on or not. Automuck is for non-showdown hands. If it's turned on your cards get mucked automatically but if it's off you get given the option to show them.
This.^^^^^ To further clarify, a showdowned hand may be mucked at the table live (an all-in of course is shown live if HU), but it will
show up when you click on hand history. It will show up there for everyone at the table to see. It doesn't show up for observers.